A still from Ghawre Bairey Aaj (2019).
Across three distinct moments in Indian cinema, Parineeta, Ghawre Bairey Aaj and Earth explore love triangles that question female desire and agency within the larger puzzle of life.
In her 2009 novel, In the Country of Deceit, Shashi Deshpande’s protagonist, Devayani, reflects on the mutable nature of life: “Nothing remains unchanged. Love gets diluted, hate is forgotten and friendship and enmity keep shifting all the time. One day, when you look back, you will ask yourself—what was it all about.” (257)
What, indeed, is life, this enigmatic journey—or paheli zindagani—ultimately about? Perhaps it is about the choices we make: whom to love, whom to befriend, and whom to leave behind. Yet, for women, the exercise of choice and agency is rarely so straightforward. This is particularly evident in the familiar trope of the love triangle in Indian cinema, where a woman’s desires and decisions are often shaped, negotiated, and constrained by the social circumstances in which she finds herself.
One such three-way complication is presented in Parineeta a novel, written in 1914 by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay, an influential Bengali writer whose works explored class, gender, marriage, family and social conventions. The 2005 film, directed by Pradeep Sarkar and produced by Vidhu Vinod Chopra, retains the love triangle and social preoccupations of the novel but relocates the story to 1960s Calcutta.
In an iconic scene, which offers an insight into Calcutta’s night life at the Moulin Rouge, the song “Kaisi Paheli Zindagani,” captures the contrasts between the glamour and apparent freedom of the cabaret world with the more restrictive domestic environment inhabited by Lalita (Vidya Balan) and Shekhar (Saif Ali Khan), who are neighbours, friends, and lovers. The mood of the song is philosophical and slightly bittersweet, asking about the paheli—this puzzling mystery of life—with all its unpredictable and confusing emotions of desire, joy, sensuality, and despair. The sequence also introduces the film’s wider concern with the relationship between performance, gender, and social expectation, and sets up the question: What is life if not but a series of enigmatic decisions?
For women, the exercise of choice and agency is rarely so straightforward. This is particularly evident in the familiar trope of the love triangle in Indian cinema, where a woman’s desires and decisions are often shaped, negotiated and constrained by the social circumstances in which she finds herself.
Cabaret is, by its very nature, a form of enactment: people put on costumes, assume roles and perform for an audience. In Parineeta, the idea of acting or role playing is significant because characters are continually having to conform to expectations and fulfil familial obligations. The film explores what happens when there is a love triangle and a woman has to make choices to assert her identity and seeks recognition beyond her performance of the role as a daughter, wife, or object of male desire.
At the centre of the film is Lalita’s struggle to be accepted as a person in her own right. Throughout, we see how she struggles against the expectations and restrictions placed on her by her family, social class, gender, and financial situation. When Girish (Sanjay Dutt), an outsider, enters the dynamic, and invites the family to Moulin Rouge, Shekhar becomes angry with Lalita and chides her. She responds, “Have I ever gone anywhere without asking you? You’re always yelling at me.” Her response exposes a contradiction in their relationship: She is with him out of her own free will and enjoys his friendship, but at the same time, he constrains her independence. She has her own family and social life, yet she has internalised the expectation that she must seek his permission. While she has accepted that his jealousy is a form of control over her mobility and choices, she is remarkably direct about her own emotions and desires. She does not present her love for Shekhar as something that she ought to be ashamed about to preserve an image of feminine modesty. She says to him, calmly, claiming ownership over her emotional life: “I am married and so I can say these things. I feel no shame, no fear.”
Lalita asserts her voice and choice throughout the film, which leads the viewer scene by scene to question: Will her choices be respected, or will she be manipulated or cowered into accepting a different fate because of the other characters?
Despite being capable of much more, Lalita works as an assistant for Shekhar’s father, in a male-dominated office environment. However, working gives her some independence, even though her opportunities are still limited by her gender and social class. At home, at work and in social settings, Lalita faces different forms of dependence, while Girish’s arrival offers the possibility of something different. He presents Lalita with the option of a marriage based on a new relationship which is possibly more respectful, the opportunity to leave Calcutta, and be more financially independent. As a less known, but nonetheless charming and more emotionally stable character, he is an alternative to Shekhar’s possessiveness, suggesting that with him Lalita may also have more liberty. However, this apparent freedom is complicated by Girish’s financial generosity. From the beginning, money plays an important role in their relationship. His help allows Lalita to pay off her family’s debt, but this also creates a sense of indebtedness that may limit her emotional freedom and make it harder for her to feel truly independent of him.
Who should Lalita choose? In Parineeta, female desire is shaped by the influence and expectations of the men around her. For Lalita, the choice is not simply between two men, but between two different lives. On the one hand, Shekhar represents love, familiarity, and emotional attachment, but his love is complicated by jealousy and possessiveness. On the other, Girish appears to offer her greater freedom and independence, although this too comes at a price, given the sense of obligation created by his financial generosity. Neither option offers Lalita complete freedom; both come with their own expectations and limitations.
The question of desire and freedom becomes even more complex in Aparna Sen’s Ghawre Bairey Aaj (2019). Like Parineeta, this film also relies on a love triangle to examine women’s freedom and choices but places the question within a very different social context. Yet both films complicate the idea of male-given freedom. If a man determines the conditions under which a woman is permitted to make choices about how to be ‘free,’ can that freedom ever be entirely autonomous? And does moving beyond the domestic space necessarily free women from the relationships through which their choices are understood?
The historical difference between the films also changes the question. Parineeta primarily frames female agency through romance, class, and respectability, whereas Ghawre Bairey Aaj expands the idea into caste, politics, nationalism and modern identity. Across the twenty-year gap between them, the films present female agency, choices, and opportunities alongside varying forms of constraint. Nothing has changed; it has only become more complex.
Ghawre Bairey Aaj is a contemporary variation of Rabindranath Tagore’s Ghare Baire which was first adapted by Satyajit Ray in 1984. In Tagore’s original text, the Ghare (Home) is the safe, private inner world, and the Baire (World) is the dangerous, public outer sphere. Written in 1916 against the background of the Swadeshi movement and the 1905 Partition of Bengal, the novel centres on Bimala (Tuhina Das0, a woman who begins to experience life beyond the domestic sphere and discovers desire; Nikhil (Anirban Bhattacharya), her husband, who believes in liberalism and attempts to give her freedom; and Sandip (Jisshu Sengupta), the charismatic nationalist whose politics and raw sexuality draw Bimala towards him.
In her adaptation, Sen retains the central love triangle but relocates it to contemporary India, replacing the historical context of the Swadeshi movement with the tensions of modern political polarisation, nationalism, religious identity, caste, and gender. The transformation of Bimala into Brinda is particularly significant to Sen’s reworking of the story. Unlike Bimala, Brinda is a Dalit woman whose identity is already shaped by caste and by her adoption into Nikhilesh’s upper-caste family. This change is more than a simple shift in character or name; it raises a deeper question of who has the power to define a woman’s identity. In Sen’s film, this question is present from the very beginning, as Brinda enters the world with an identity that has already been shaped by others: through her caste, her adoption into Nikhilesh’s family, her education and even the name she is given. Her struggle for independence is therefore not simply about discovering who she wants to be, but about confronting the identities and expectations that have been imposed upon her.
Both films present male characters who offer the female protagonists different possibilities. While Shekhar’s love for Lalita is often controlling, and her attempts at independence become a source of conflict, Nikhilesh deliberately encourages Brinda to explore the world beyond the domestic. Like Girish in Parineeta, Sandip enters the domestic world as a figure offering something new. In Ghawre Bairey Aaj, however, this takes the form of intellectual freedom and political activism. But what will Brinda make of this invitation?
If a man determines the conditions under which a woman is permitted to make choices about how to be ‘free,’ can that freedom ever be entirely autonomous? And does moving beyond the domestic space necessarily free women from the relationships through which their choices are understood?
Brinda is already educated, socially mobile, and politically aware; she does not need Sandip to introduce her to the world beyond the home. Sen therefore asks a different question: what does freedom mean for a woman whose choices are already shaped by caste, class and the identities others have given her?
Lalita and Brinda both possess desires of their own, yet their ability to fulfil them remains shaped by the men in their lives. Both films question whether a man who seeks to ‘liberate’ a woman is truly granting her freedom, or simply replacing one form of dependence with another, in which her choices remain bound by male power.
Just as the jazz track in the Moulin Rouge scene in Parineeta creates a momentary contrast between the domestic world and the outside streets of Calcutta, the classical music of “Chhaye Badra” in Ghawre Bairey Aaj establishes a distinct atmosphere around the growing intimacy between Brinda and Sandip. The song acts as an auditory catalyst, drawing Brinda beyond the familiarity of domestic life and towards Sandip’s volatile political world. The mood it creates is important because Brinda’s movement into the baire initially feels liberating rather than threatening. As she begins to explore her desires and intellectual interests, she appears to be discovering possibilities beyond the boundaries of the home. Yet, as the film unfolds, this newfound freedom becomes increasingly uncertain, revealing the restrictions and tensions that lie beneath it.
Sandip questions what it means that Bimala became Brinda after being taken into Nikhilesh’s upper-class Bengali family. He asks sarcastically whether they have “Brahmanised the Dalit girl?” Brinda’s renaming exposes the limits of a freedom granted by others. Although Nikhilesh’s family gives her an education, social status and a home, it also redefines her identity on its own terms. Her struggle begins within the home itself. When she is invited to sit at the dinner table, she chooses instead to sit on the floor, where she feels more comfortable and more at home in herself. The family may see their actions as having liberated Brinda, but her new life brings its own restrictions. She must continually negotiate the expectations of a family and society shaped by different class and caste positions. Although this world offers her opportunities, it also places pressure on her to adapt to its values, sometimes at the expense of parts of her own identity. Sandip complicates this idea of freedom further. His attraction to Brinda becomes entangled with his political ideals, making it difficult to separate his language of liberation from his personal desire for her.
Lalita is expected to become the respectable wife, defined by romantic love and the expectations of marriage. Brinda, meanwhile, is a Dalit girl who has become an educated woman within an upper-class Bengali family and must embody a particular idea of the ‘liberated’ modern wife.
Lalita is expected to become the respectable wife, defined by romantic love and the expectations of marriage. Brinda, meanwhile, is a Dalit girl who has become an educated woman within an upper-class Bengali family and must embody a particular idea of the ‘liberated’ modern wife.
What, then, are they really being asked to choose? Perhaps this is where the love triangle becomes so revealing. It appears to offer a woman a choice between two men, but both films invite us to question whether choosing between them is really the choice that matters.
In Parineeta, Shekhar asks Lalita to account for her behaviour, while in Ghawre Bairey Aaj, Nikhilesh asks Brinda to articulate her desires. He asks her, “Do you love Sandip?” This question subtly reverses the dynamic in Parineeta. Nikhilesh is the supposedly liberal husband, who wants to give Brinda the freedom to explore the world beyond the home. Yet even this freedom becomes something she must explain in relation to him and his question.
In both films, female agency is mediated through a man’s recognition of it. The women may make their own choices, but those choices are continually questioned, interpreted, and given meaning by the men around them.
In Earth, Deepa Mehta takes this question further, presenting a woman who chooses the object of her desire without hesitation, only to find that the consequences of her choice are ultimately determined by the men around her. Based on Bapsi Sidhwa’s novel Cracking India (1991), Earth offers a different perspective on the love triangle, presenting it largely through the eyes of a child, Lenny. At its centre is the relationship between Shanta (Nandita Das), Hassan, and Dil. Shanta is portrayed as an independent woman who is confident in her desires and exercises her freedom to choose. However, Lenny’s childlike perspective shapes how the audience sees the unfolding relationships. She observes adult sexuality, desire, and jealousy without fully understanding their consequences.
The song “Banno Rani” in Earth carries a symbolic weight that goes beyond its role as a dance number. Sung during a mehndi celebration, its cheerful mood foreshadows the film’s later exploration of how little control women can have over their own futures. The celebration of marriage is ironic, because what is being celebrated is not happy: Papoo, who belongs to the sweeper community, is being forced into child marriage. As the adults and children discuss the wedding, Lenny is jokingly asked whom she would like to marry. Not fully understanding the seriousness of Papoo’s situation, Lenny innocently lists her possibilities: “I can marry the Ice-Candy-Wallah, the Malishwallah, the Zoo-wallah... or Adi!” For Lenny, marriage appears to offer a choice between different possibilities. Papoo’s situation exposes how far this freedom is from reality. Through this contrast, Lenny begins to understand that not every girl has the privilege of choosing whom she will marry.
As Lenny’s caretaker, Shanta is responsible for protecting her, yet the audience is sometimes left to question whether she puts her own desires before her responsibilities. Because we see Shanta largely through Lenny’s eyes, we may judge her more harshly, forgetting that she is also a woman entitled to a life beyond her role as Lenny’s ayah.
Shanta is a woman who knows what she wants. She is admired by both Dil Nawaz (Aamir Khan) and Hasan (Rahul Khanna). She is confident in expressing her opinions and setting boundaries with those around her. When political tensions begin to rise and her friends argue over whether Hindus, Muslims, or Sikhs will control Lahore, Shanta refuses to allow religious divisions disrupt the harmony of their friendship group: “Unless you stop talking about Hindus and Muslims, I’ll stop coming to the park.” She is equally direct with her suitors. When Dil tries to linger near her workplace under the pretence of helping her with chores, she tells him, “Now you’d better go. I have work.” When he insists, she relents, but on her own terms: “Okay, but only for ten minutes. Get lost!”
Shanta’s strongest act of independence comes when she chooses Hasan over Dil. Despite the growing communal tensions surrounding a Hindu woman loving a Muslim man in 1947 Lahore, she follows her heart and chooses Hasan.
What is significant, however, is how the men’s responses to her choices change throughout the film. In the first half, the wider circle of working-class men, including the Sikh zoo-keeper, the Hindu cook, and the Muslim butcher all appear to respect Shanta’s authority. When she threatens to leave if they continue fighting over religion, they fall silent. Yet, as the political climate becomes increasingly hostile, this respect begins to unravel. The men increasingly allow their religious identities and communal loyalties to take precedence over their relationship with Shanta. Her authority, once enough to hold them together, is gradually undermined by the divisions around them.
Hasan, whom Shanta marries, is presented as a man who respects her right to make her own choices. When she accepts his proposal, he does not treat her decision as a victory or an act of male possession. Instead, he recognises the danger she faces as a Hindu woman in an increasingly radicalised Lahore. He therefore suggests that they move to Amritsar, where he is willing to convert to Hinduism. His response suggests that he is prepared to put Shanta’s safety and wishes before his own religious identity.
“Kaisi Paheli Zindagani” places desire within performance and spectacle; “Chhaye Badra” accompanies Brinda’s movement beyond the domestic world; while “Banno Rani” sung at a child’s forced marriage foreshadows the intrusion of wider circumstances on a woman’s choices and desires.
Dil, by contrast, continues to see Shanta as someone he has a right to possess. Having secretly witnessed the growing relationship between Shanta and Hasan, he cannot accept her rejection. His wounded pride becomes entangled with the wider communal hatred developing around him, until his personal resentment turns into violence. He eventually murders Hasan and leads a Muslim mob to the Parsi house where Shanta is hiding. In his final act of betrayal, he exploits his friendship with Lenny to trick her into revealing Shanta’s whereabouts. The contrast between the two men is significant: while Hasan accepts Shanta’s right to choose, Dil responds to her independence by seeking to punish and control her.
What is striking is that Shanta does not change; throughout the film, she is clear about what she wants and is unafraid to express it. It is the world around her that changes. As a result, her ability to make her own choices is gradually eroded by circumstances over which she has no control. Her story reveals how a woman’s independence can be undermined not by any change in her own desires, but by the changing attitudes and allegiances of those around her.
The songs in all three films bring us back to the question of female desire. What are the limits placed upon women’s desires? “Kaisi Paheli Zindagani” places desire within performance and spectacle; “Chhaye Badra” accompanies Brinda’s movement beyond the domestic world; while “Banno Rani” sung at a child’s forced marriage foreshadows the intrusion of wider circumstances on a woman’s choices and desires. Each song captures a moment in which women are watched, desired or imagined by others.
Across three very different moments in Indian cinema, Parineeta, Ghawre Bairey Aaj and Earth begin with what appears to be a relatively simple question: whom does a woman choose to love? Yet the more closely we look, the less simple this question becomes. Lalita can choose, but her choices are entangled with love, money and social expectations. Brinda can move beyond the domestic world, but the identity from which she makes her choices has already been shaped by her adopted family and her caste. Shanta knows what she wants and chooses Hasan, but Partition transforms a personal choice into a communal one, with consequences beyond her control.
Perhaps, then, the love triangle is less about choosing between two men than about the conditions under which a woman is allowed to desire. These women are not without agency. Indeed, what makes their stories so compelling is that they actively exercise it. They speak, refuse, decide, fall in love, and attempt to define themselves. Yet their choices acquire meanings beyond their own intentions, shaped by the men around them and by the societies in which they live.
Perhaps this is what paheli zindagani ultimately suggests: that life remains something of a puzzle, and that we may come to understand our choices differently only in retrospect. The song “Kaisi Paheli Zindagani” asks: “Thaama, haan roka isko kisne? Haan ye toh behta paani.” Who has held it back? Who has stopped it? It is, after all, like flowing water.
Desire, too, continues to flow, often beyond our attempts to contain or direct it.
Returning to Deshpande’s question—’What was it all about in the end?’—perhaps what matters most is that the possibility of choice is never entirely relinquished in matters of love and desire.
***
Farah Ahamed has been published in Ploughshares, The White Review, Los Angeles Review of Books, The Massachusetts Review, World Literature Today, The Markaz Review, and elsewhere. She is the editor of Period Matters: Menstruation in South Asia (Pan Macmillan India, 2022), described by Book Riot as an “essential” book “about the female body that dispel[s] misconceptions.” She is a human rights lawyer and lives in London. You can read more of her work here. She is on Instagram: @farah_ahamed_author and X: @FarahAhamed.